| 1 | |  Wrexham | 46 | 34 | 9 | 3 | 116 | 43 | 73 | 111 | M17:00 | 07/04/23 | R 42  FC Halifax Town 3 Wrexham 1 G17:00 | 10/04/23 | R 43 Wrexham 3 Notts County 2 B14:45 | 15/04/23 | R 44 Barnet FC 0 Wrexham 0 G21:45 | 18/04/23 | R 27 Wrexham 3 Yeovil Town 0 G20:30 | 22/04/23 | R 45 Wrexham 3 Boreham Wood FC 1 B19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 Torquay United 1 Wrexham 1 |
| 2 | |  Notts County | 46 | 32 | 11 | 3 | 117 | 42 | 75 | 107 | G19:30 | 15/04/23 | R 44 Notts County 3 Woking 0 G17:00 | 22/04/23 | R 45 Maidstone United FC 2 Notts County 5 B19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 Notts County 1 York City FC 1 G14:30 | 07/05/23 | R semifinal Notts County 3 Boreham Wood FC 2 G17:30 | 13/05/23 | R final Chesterfield FC (3) 2 Notts County (4) 2 G17:30 | 13/05/23 | R final Chesterfield FC (3) 2 Notts County (4) 2 |
| 3 | |  Chesterfield FC | 46 | 25 | 9 | 12 | 81 | 52 | 29 | 84 | G21:45 | 18/04/23 | R 32 Chesterfield FC 5 Torquay United 1 M17:00 | 22/04/23 | R 45 Bromley 2 Chesterfield FC 0 G19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 Chesterfield FC 4 Maidstone United FC 0 G17:30 | 07/05/23 | R semifinal Chesterfield FC 3 Bromley 2 M17:30 | 13/05/23 | R final Chesterfield FC (3) 2 Notts County (4) 2 M17:30 | 13/05/23 | R final Chesterfield FC (3) 2 Notts County (4) 2 |
| 4 | |  Woking | 46 | 24 | 10 | 12 | 71 | 48 | 23 | 82 | B17:00 | 10/04/23 | R 43 Woking 1 Southend United 1 M19:30 | 15/04/23 | R 44 Notts County 3 Woking 0 G17:00 | 22/04/23 | R 45 Woking 2 Gateshead 1 M21:45 | 25/04/23 | R 41 Woking 0 FC Halifax Town 1 G19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 Solihull Moors 0 Woking 1 M21:45 | 03/05/23 | R quarterfinal Woking 1 Bromley 2 |
| 5 | |  Barnet FC | 46 | 21 | 11 | 14 | 75 | 67 | 8 | 74 | B17:00 | 10/04/23 | R 43 Maidstone United FC 0 Barnet FC 0 B14:45 | 15/04/23 | R 44 Barnet FC 0 Wrexham 0 G21:45 | 18/04/23 | R 38 Barnet FC 1 Solihull Moors 0 B17:00 | 22/04/23 | R 45 Maidenhead United FC 1 Barnet FC 1 M19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 Barnet FC 0 Dagenham and Redbridge FC 2 M21:45 | 02/05/23 | R quarterfinal Barnet FC 1 Boreham Wood FC 2 |
| 6 | |  Boreham Wood FC | 46 | 19 | 15 | 12 | 52 | 40 | 12 | 72 | G17:00 | 15/04/23 | R 44 Boreham Wood FC 1 Wealdstone 0 M20:30 | 22/04/23 | R 45 Wrexham 3 Boreham Wood FC 1 M21:45 | 25/04/23 | R 38 Boreham Wood FC 0 Gateshead 2 G19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 Boreham Wood FC 1 Yeovil Town 0 G21:45 | 02/05/23 | R quarterfinal Barnet FC 1 Boreham Wood FC 2 M14:30 | 07/05/23 | R semifinal Notts County 3 Boreham Wood FC 2 |
| 7 | |  Bromley | 46 | 18 | 17 | 11 | 68 | 53 | 15 | 71 | G17:00 | 15/04/23 | R 44 Gateshead 0 Bromley 3 B21:45 | 18/04/23 | R 32 FC Halifax Town 1 Bromley 1 G17:00 | 22/04/23 | R 45 Bromley 2 Chesterfield FC 0 B19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 Oldham Athletic 1 Bromley 1 G21:45 | 03/05/23 | R quarterfinal Woking 1 Bromley 2 M17:30 | 07/05/23 | R semifinal Chesterfield FC 3 Bromley 2 |
| 8 | |  Southend United | 46 | 20 | 9 | 17 | 57 | 45 | 12 | 69 | G17:00 | 07/04/23 | R 42 Southend United 2 Maidstone United FC 0 B17:00 | 10/04/23 | R 43 Woking 1 Southend United 1 G17:00 | 15/04/23 | R 44 Southend United 2 Dagenham and Redbridge FC 0 M21:45 | 18/04/23 Oldham Athletic 2 Southend United 0 G17:00 | 22/04/23 | R 45 Scunthorpe United 1 Southend United 3 G19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 Southend United 2 Wealdstone 1 |
| 9 | |  Eastleigh | 46 | 19 | 10 | 17 | 56 | 57 | -1 | 67 | M17:00 | 07/04/23 | R 42 Torquay United 2 Eastleigh 0 B17:00 | 10/04/23 | R 43 Eastleigh 3 Aldershot Town FC 3 M21:45 | 12/04/23 | R 41 Eastleigh 2 Gateshead 5 M17:00 | 15/04/23 | R 44 Chesterfield FC 3 Eastleigh 2 B17:00 | 22/04/23 | R 45 Eastleigh 0 Solihull Moors 0 B19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 FC Halifax Town 1 Eastleigh 1 |
| 10 | |  Dagenham and Redbridge FC | 46 | 18 | 9 | 19 | 61 | 72 | -11 | 63 | G19:00 | 07/04/23 | R 42 Boreham Wood FC 0 Dagenham and Redbridge FC 1 M17:00 | 10/04/23 | R 43 Dagenham and Redbridge FC 0 Chesterfield FC 1 M17:00 | 15/04/23 | R 44 Southend United 2 Dagenham and Redbridge FC 0 B21:45 | 18/04/23 | R 38 Altrincham 2 Dagenham and Redbridge FC 2 B17:00 | 22/04/23 | R 45 Dagenham and Redbridge FC 0 FC Halifax Town 0 G19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 Barnet FC 0 Dagenham and Redbridge FC 2 |
| 11 | |  FC Halifax Town | 46 | 16 | 13 | 17 | 49 | 48 | 1 | 61 | G17:00 | 10/04/23 | R 43 York City FC 0 FC Halifax Town 3 G17:00 | 15/04/23 | R 44 FC Halifax Town 3 Maidstone United FC 0 B21:45 | 18/04/23 | R 32 FC Halifax Town 1 Bromley 1 B17:00 | 22/04/23 | R 45 Dagenham and Redbridge FC 0 FC Halifax Town 0 G21:45 | 25/04/23 | R 41 Woking 0 FC Halifax Town 1 B19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 FC Halifax Town 1 Eastleigh 1 |
| 12 | |  Oldham Athletic | 46 | 16 | 13 | 17 | 63 | 64 | -1 | 61 | B17:00 | 07/04/23 | R 42 Oldham Athletic 2 Altrincham 2 G17:00 | 10/04/23 | R 43 Scunthorpe United 0 Oldham Athletic 2 G17:00 | 15/04/23 | R 44 Oldham Athletic 1 Maidenhead United FC 0 G21:45 | 18/04/23 Oldham Athletic 2 Southend United 0 G17:00 | 22/04/23 | R 45 Yeovil Town 0 Oldham Athletic 3 B19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 Oldham Athletic 1 Bromley 1 |
| 13 | |  Wealdstone | 46 | 16 | 12 | 18 | 57 | 72 | -15 | 60 | M17:00 | 07/04/23 | R 42 Notts County 3 Wealdstone 0 M17:00 | 15/04/23 | R 44 Boreham Wood FC 1 Wealdstone 0 M21:45 | 18/04/23 | R 41 Wealdstone 0 Aldershot Town FC 1 B17:00 | 22/04/23 | R 45 Wealdstone 2 Dorking Wanderers 2 G21:45 | 25/04/23 | R 43 Wealdstone 3 Solihull Moors 0 M19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 Southend United 2 Wealdstone 1 |
| 14 | |  Gateshead | 46 | 15 | 15 | 16 | 67 | 62 | 5 | 59 | G21:45 | 12/04/23 | R 41 Eastleigh 2 Gateshead 5 M17:00 | 15/04/23 | R 44 Gateshead 0 Bromley 3 B21:45 | 18/04/23 | R 28 Gateshead 0 Dorking Wanderers 0 M17:00 | 22/04/23 | R 45 Woking 2 Gateshead 1 G21:45 | 25/04/23 | R 38 Boreham Wood FC 0 Gateshead 2 G19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 Gateshead 4 Maidenhead United FC 0 |
| 15 | |  Solihull Moors | 46 | 15 | 13 | 18 | 62 | 66 | -4 | 58 | B17:00 | 07/04/23 | R 42 Solihull Moors 1 Maidenhead United FC 1 B17:00 | 15/04/23 | R 44 Solihull Moors 2 Yeovil Town 2 M21:45 | 18/04/23 | R 38 Barnet FC 1 Solihull Moors 0 B17:00 | 22/04/23 | R 45 Eastleigh 0 Solihull Moors 0 M21:45 | 25/04/23 | R 43 Wealdstone 3 Solihull Moors 0 M19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 Solihull Moors 0 Woking 1 |
| 16 | |  Dorking Wanderers | 46 | 16 | 9 | 21 | 67 | 91 | -24 | 57 | M17:00 | 07/04/23 | R 42 Dorking Wanderers 1 Woking 2 G17:00 | 10/04/23 | R 43 Yeovil Town 0 Dorking Wanderers 1 G17:00 | 15/04/23 | R 44 Dorking Wanderers 3 Altrincham 2 B21:45 | 18/04/23 | R 28 Gateshead 0 Dorking Wanderers 0 B17:00 | 22/04/23 | R 45 Wealdstone 2 Dorking Wanderers 2 G19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 Dorking Wanderers 2 Scunthorpe United 1 |
| 17 | |  Altrincham | 46 | 14 | 14 | 18 | 68 | 82 | -14 | 56 | B17:00 | 07/04/23 | R 42 Oldham Athletic 2 Altrincham 2 M17:00 | 10/04/23 | R 43 Altrincham 0 Gateshead 1 M17:00 | 15/04/23 | R 44 Dorking Wanderers 3 Altrincham 2 B21:45 | 18/04/23 | R 38 Altrincham 2 Dagenham and Redbridge FC 2 B17:00 | 22/04/23 | R 45 Altrincham 2 Torquay United 2 B19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 Aldershot Town FC 1 Altrincham 1 |
| 18 | |  Aldershot Town FC | 46 | 14 | 11 | 21 | 64 | 76 | -12 | 53 | B17:00 | 07/04/23 | R 42 Aldershot Town FC 1 Yeovil Town 1 B17:00 | 10/04/23 | R 43 Eastleigh 3 Aldershot Town FC 3 G17:00 | 15/04/23 | R 44 Aldershot Town FC 2 Scunthorpe United 1 G21:45 | 18/04/23 | R 41 Wealdstone 0 Aldershot Town FC 1 B17:00 | 22/04/23 | R 45 York City FC 2 Aldershot Town FC 2 B19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 Aldershot Town FC 1 Altrincham 1 |
| 19 | |  York City FC | 46 | 13 | 12 | 21 | 55 | 63 | -8 | 51 | G21:45 | 03/04/23 | R 41 York City FC 1 Barnet FC 0 G17:00 | 07/04/23 | R 42 Chesterfield FC 1 York City FC 3 M17:00 | 10/04/23 | R 43 York City FC 0 FC Halifax Town 3 M17:00 | 15/04/23 | R 44 Torquay United 3 York City FC 2 B17:00 | 22/04/23 | R 45 York City FC 2 Aldershot Town FC 2 B19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 Notts County 1 York City FC 1 |
| 20 | |  Maidenhead United FC | 46 | 13 | 11 | 22 | 47 | 66 | -19 | 50 | B17:00 | 01/04/23 | R 41 Maidenhead United FC 0 Chesterfield FC 0 B17:00 | 07/04/23 | R 42 Solihull Moors 1 Maidenhead United FC 1 M17:00 | 10/04/23 | R 43 Maidenhead United FC 1 Torquay United 3 M17:00 | 15/04/23 | R 44 Oldham Athletic 1 Maidenhead United FC 0 B17:00 | 22/04/23 | R 45 Maidenhead United FC 1 Barnet FC 1 M19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 Gateshead 4 Maidenhead United FC 0 |
| 21 | |  Torquay United | 46 | 12 | 12 | 22 | 58 | 80 | -22 | 48 | G17:00 | 07/04/23 | R 42 Torquay United 2 Eastleigh 0 G17:00 | 10/04/23 | R 43 Maidenhead United FC 1 Torquay United 3 G17:00 | 15/04/23 | R 44 Torquay United 3 York City FC 2 M21:45 | 18/04/23 | R 32 Chesterfield FC 5 Torquay United 1 B17:00 | 22/04/23 | R 45 Altrincham 2 Torquay United 2 B19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 Torquay United 1 Wrexham 1 |
| 22 | |  Yeovil Town | 46 | 7 | 19 | 20 | 35 | 60 | -25 | 40 | B17:00 | 07/04/23 | R 42 Aldershot Town FC 1 Yeovil Town 1 M17:00 | 10/04/23 | R 43 Yeovil Town 0 Dorking Wanderers 1 B17:00 | 15/04/23 | R 44 Solihull Moors 2 Yeovil Town 2 M21:45 | 18/04/23 | R 27 Wrexham 3 Yeovil Town 0 M17:00 | 22/04/23 | R 45 Yeovil Town 0 Oldham Athletic 3 M19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 Boreham Wood FC 1 Yeovil Town 0 |
| 23 | |  Scunthorpe United | 46 | 8 | 10 | 28 | 49 | 87 | -38 | 34 | M17:00 | 01/04/23 | R 41 Scunthorpe United 0 Torquay United 1 M17:00 | 07/04/23 | R 42 Gateshead 2 Scunthorpe United 0 M17:00 | 10/04/23 | R 43 Scunthorpe United 0 Oldham Athletic 2 M17:00 | 15/04/23 | R 44 Aldershot Town FC 2 Scunthorpe United 1 M17:00 | 22/04/23 | R 45 Scunthorpe United 1 Southend United 3 M19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 Dorking Wanderers 2 Scunthorpe United 1 |
| 24 | |  Maidstone United FC | 46 | 5 | 10 | 31 | 45 | 104 | -59 | 25 | M17:00 | 01/04/23 | R 41 Maidstone United FC 0 Boreham Wood FC 4 M17:00 | 07/04/23 | R 42 Southend United 2 Maidstone United FC 0 B17:00 | 10/04/23 | R 43 Maidstone United FC 0 Barnet FC 0 M17:00 | 15/04/23 | R 44 FC Halifax Town 3 Maidstone United FC 0 M17:00 | 22/04/23 | R 45 Maidstone United FC 2 Notts County 5 M19:30 | 29/04/23 | R 46 Chesterfield FC 4 Maidstone United FC 0 |
